Skip to content
Cookery Know-howIngredients, methods and kitchen questions

Ingredient guide

The Potato Guide

The same potato is not best for everything. Here is which one to buy for chips, mash, roast potatoes and the rest, why it works, and how to store potatoes safely.

  • Solanum tuberosum
  • Floury, waxy or all-rounder
  • UK and US varieties
  • Store cool, dark and dry
Illustration of floury, all-rounder and waxy potatoes on a wooden board: brown russet-style, red-skinned and small yellow salad potatoes
Illustration

Potatoes differ most in how much dry matter they contain, and most of that dry matter is starch. High-starch potatoes cook up dry, fluffy and “mealy”; low-starch potatoes are moist, firm and hold their shape. That one difference decides what each potato is good for. [1]

In Britain potatoes are usually sold as floury, waxy or all-rounders. In the US they are sold by type: russet (floury), red (waxy), and white and yellow (in between). [2]

Quick answerThe best potato for…

Chips, mash, roasts and the rest: which type, which variety on each side of the Atlantic, and why.

DishTypeBest UK potatoesBest US potatoesWhy, and our recipe
Chips and friesFlouryMaris Piper, King EdwardRussetHigh dry matter means less water to drive out and less oil soaked up; low sugars let them fry golden, not dark brown. [1,3,10]Chips (French Fries)
MashFloury (or yellow for a creamy, buttery mash)King Edward, Maris Piper, RoosterRusset; Yukon GoldFloury potatoes fall apart into a light, fluffy mash; yellow potatoes give a denser, smoother, buttery one. Waxy potatoes go gluey. [2,4,5]Mashed Potatoes (Pommes Purée)
Roast potatoesFlouryMaris Piper, King Edward, RoosterRusset (crispest); Yukon Gold (creamier)The fluffy outside roughs up when shaken and fries into a crunchy crust in the hot fat. [3,12]Roast Potatoes
Jacket (baked) potatoesFlouryMaris Piper, King EdwardRussetHigh-starch potatoes bake to a dry, fluffy middle; the russet is the US “potato of choice for baking”. [1,2]Jacket Potatoes (Baked Potatoes)
Hash brownsFlouryMaris Piper, King EdwardRussetDry, starchy shreds crisp best once squeezed dry; their starch helps the shreds hold together. [10,1]Hash Browns
RöstiWaxy or all-rounderCharlotte, Desiree, Maris PiperYukon GoldFirmer potatoes grate into neat shreds that brown without turning to mush (our original card: “good waxy potatoes”). [6,7]Rösti
Sauté potatoesWaxy or all-rounderCharlotte, DesireeRed, Yukon GoldLow-dry-matter potatoes keep their shape when boiled and then fried in slices or cubes. [1,6]Sauté Potatoes · Saute Potatoes Lyonnaise
Potato salad and boiled new potatoesWaxyCharlotte, Anya, Jersey RoyalRedWaxy potatoes stay firm when boiled and dressed; floury ones break up and soak up the dressing. [1,2,7,9]Potato Salad · New Potatoes with Mint
Gratins and dauphinoiseAll-rounder or flouryMaris Piper, King Edward, DesireeYukon Gold, russetTheir starch thickens the cream as the slices soften; very waxy potatoes stay firm and leave the sauce thin. [14,6]Dauphinoise Potatoes · Scalloped Potatoes with Onion · Savoury Potatoes [boulangere]
GnocchiFlouryMaris Piper, King EdwardRussetThe drier the potato, the less flour it needs and the lighter the gnocchi; bake rather than boil. [13]Potato Gnocchi
Wedges and smashed potatoesFloury or all-rounder; small waxy for smashedMaris Piper, King Edward; small CharlottesRusset, Yukon Gold; small redsFloury potatoes give fluffy middles; small waxy potatoes keep their shape when squashed flat. [1,2]Potato Wedges with Basil · Smashed Potatoes
SoupFloury (smooth soup); waxy (chunky soup)Maris Piper, King EdwardRussetFloury potatoes break down and thicken the soup; waxy pieces stay whole in a brothy soup. [1]Leek & Potato Soup

The three typesFloury, waxy or all-rounder?

The scienceStarch and dry matter: why potatoes behave differently

Growers and processors measure a potato’s dry matter by its specific gravity: the more starch, the heavier the potato is for its size. Between 60 and 80 per cent of the dry matter is starch, so a “high-solids” potato is a starchy, floury one. This is the table US seed certifiers use: [1]

Specific gravityDry matterTextureTypical uses
Below 1.060Below 16.2%Very soggyPan frying, salads, canning
1.060–1.06916.2–18.1%SoggyPan frying, salads, boiling
1.070–1.07918.2–20.2%WaxyBoiling, mashing; fair for chips
1.080–1.08920.3–22.3%Mealy, dryBaking, crisps, frozen French fries; can fall apart when boiled
Above 1.089Above 22.3%Very mealy or dryBaking, French fries, crisps; falls apart when boiled

Why it matters for frying: frying drives the water out of a chip and replaces it with oil, so watery, low-dry-matter potatoes soak up more oil and go soggy. And even very low levels of sugars (glucose and fructose) make chips and fries turn dark brown, which is why chip potatoes are chosen for low sugar as well as high starch. [1]

UKBritish and Irish varieties

USAmerican varieties

StorageStoring potatoes

Food safetyGreen potatoes, solanine and food safety

A Maris Piper potato turned green after being left in the light
Greened Maris Piper, from our original Potato Page.

Potatoes make natural toxins called glycoalkaloids (mainly solanine and chaconine). Low levels are normal and give potatoes part of their flavour, but light, damage, poor storage and sprouting make the potato produce more. Light also makes it produce chlorophyll, which is why a potato that has been left in the light turns green: the green chlorophyll is harmless in itself, but it is a sign the glycoalkaloids have probably risen too. [16,18]

HistoryA short, sourced history of the potato in Europe

  1. 7,000–10,000 years ago

    The potato was domesticated in the Andes, in what is now southern Peru and north-western Bolivia; genetic studies show a single origin. [19]

  2. 1567

    The first written mention of the potato in Europe: a receipt dated 28 November 1567 for potatoes shipped from Las Palmas in the Canary Islands to Antwerp. [20]

  3. c.1570

    Potatoes arrive in mainland Spain, the first of two ports of entry into Europe. [20]

  4. 1588–1593

    The second route, via the British Isles. Sir Francis Drake, or Sir Walter Raleigh’s employee Thomas Harriot, are commonly credited with bringing potatoes to England. [20]

  5. 1588 and 1601

    The botanist Carolus Clusius paints “Papas Peruanorum” (the potato of the Peruvians) from a specimen in the Low Countries, and in 1601 reports potatoes in common use in northern Italy. [20]

  6. 1772–1789

    Antoine-Augustin Parmentier, who ate potatoes as a prisoner of war in Prussia, champions them in France: he wins the Besançon Academy prize for the potato in 1773, the bad harvest of 1785 helps them stave off famine in the north, and in 1789 he publishes his treatise on growing them. From the 1870s many potato dishes were named after him, among them potage Parmentier (potato and leek soup) and hachis Parmentier. [21]

  7. 1845–1852

    Potato blight destroys crops across Europe. In Ireland, where many poor families lived on one bland, wet, high-yielding variety, the Lumper, the result is the Great Famine: between about 775,000 and 1.5 million deaths and a million or more emigrants. [20,22]

  8. 1902–1980

    The British favourites appear: King Edward (grown since 1902), Maris Piper (1966; the UK’s most grown potato since 1980). In North America the Russet Burbank becomes the leading potato, and Yukon Gold is released in 1980. [4,3,10,11]

Not used, because we could not find good evidence: the story that Parmentier had guards watch his potato field so that people would steal the plants. Wikipedia also notes there is no primary source for a French ban on potatoes. [21]

Cook itPotato recipes on Cookeryonline

More: all our potato dishes.

ArchiveFrom the original Potato Page

The variety, storage and nutrition charts from our first Potato Page are kept here.

Sources for this guide (22)
  1. Oregon State University, Oregon Seed Certification Service: “Potato Varieties” (dry matter and use table, adapted from Mosley and Chase, 1993)
  2. Potatoes USA: “Types of Potatoes” (russet, red, white, yellow)
  3. Wikipedia: “Maris Piper”
  4. Wikipedia: “King Edward potato”
  5. Wikipedia: “Rooster potato”
  6. Wikipedia: “Désirée potato”
  7. French seed potato catalogue (plantdepommedeterre.org): “Charlotte” (1981, Hansa × Danaé; culinary group A; dry matter slightly low)
  8. Wikipedia: “Jersey Royal”
  9. Wikipedia: “Anya potato”
  10. Wikipedia: “Russet Burbank”
  11. Wikipedia: “Yukon Gold potato”
  12. Serious Eats: J. Kenji López-Alt, “The Best Crispy Roast Potatoes Ever” (russet vs Yukon Gold)
  13. The Guardian: Felicity Cloake, “How to make gnocchi” (2022)
  14. BBC Good Food: Paul Merrett, “Dauphinoise potatoes” (King Edward or Maris Piper)
  15. GOV.UK (Food Standards Agency): “Acrylamide” (go for gold; storing raw potatoes in the fridge)
  16. Health Canada: “Glycoalkaloids in Foods”
  17. EFSA (European Food Safety Authority): “Glycoalkaloids in potatoes: public health risks assessed” (2020)
  18. Wikipedia: “Solanine” (why light, damage and sprouting raise glycoalkaloids; greening)
  19. Wikipedia: “Potato” (single origin in southern Peru and north-western Bolivia)
  20. Wikipedia: “History of the potato”
  21. Wikipedia: “Antoine-Augustin Parmentier”
  22. Wikipedia: “Great Famine (Ireland)”

Written 1 November 2026. Facts checked against the sources above on 1 November 2026; Amazon listings checked on 1 November 2026. The hero picture is an illustration, not a photograph.