Dough Products
Bread Rolls White (Soft Rolls and Baps)
Recipe No. 0123
Soft white dinner rolls, or flat floury baps, made with milk, a little butter, sugar and an egg for a tender crumb and a thin soft crust. Fresh yeast (or fast-action dried), proper kneading and proving, a moderate oven and a tea towel over them as they cool. Tips, variations and a short history below.
- Serves 12
- Cooking time 15 min (baking)
- Resting 1½–2 hrs (rising)
- Makes 12
- Freezes well (up to 1 month)
- British
- Hands-on 30 min
Method
Weigh the flour into a large bowl, add the 9 g of salt on one side and the sugar on the other, then rub in the softened butter with your fingertips until it disappears. Crumble the 20 g of fresh yeast into a jug with about 100 ml (scant ½ cup) of the lukewarm milk and water, mixed and stir until it dissolves; it does not need sugar or creaming. Using fast-action dried yeast instead? Stir 7 g of fast-action dried yeast straight into the flour, on the opposite side of the bowl from the salt, and add all the milk and water, mixed in the next step.
Add the yeast liquid, the beaten egg and most of the remaining milk and water, and mix to a soft, slightly sticky dough with no dry flour left, adding the last of the liquid only if it feels firm. Cover and leave for 10 minutes.
Knead for 10 minutes by hand (or 6–8 minutes with a dough hook) until smooth, silky and elastic. It should pass the windowpane test: a small piece stretches thin enough to let light through without tearing.
Put the dough in a lightly oiled bowl, cover and leave in a warm place for 1 to 1½ hours, until doubled. It is ready when a floured fingertip dent springs back only slowly.
Tip it out, press out the largest bubbles and divide into 12 equal pieces of about 75 g (2½ oz). Shape each into a smooth, tight ball, cupping your hand over it and rolling it in small circles on an unfloured worktop.
For soft dinner rolls, set them about 1 cm (½ in) apart on a lined baking tray so they bake into a tear-and-share batch with soft sides, or 5 cm (2 in) apart for separate rolls. For floury baps, rest the balls for 10 minutes, then flatten each with a rolling pin to about 10 cm (4 in) across and 2 cm (¾ in) thick.
Cover loosely and prove for 30–45 minutes, until almost doubled and soft and puffy. Meanwhile heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan), gas mark 6, 400°F.
Brush soft rolls gently with milk (or with a little extra beaten egg for a shiny top). For baps, dust them generously with flour instead and press a floured thumb or three fingers into the middle of each to stop them doming.
Bake on the middle shelf, without steam, for 15–18 minutes (baps 12–15 minutes), until risen and light golden. They are done when they sound hollow when tapped underneath and read 88–93°C (190–200°F) in the centre: soft, enriched rolls are fully baked at a slightly lower temperature than crusty ones and stay moister.
Move them to a wire rack and cover with a clean tea towel while they cool: the trapped steam keeps the crust soft. Leave baps for at least 20 minutes before splitting.
Tip: tap a step to tick it off as you cook.
Rate this recipe
Tried it? Rate it.
The readers’ average appears here once 5 readers have rated it.
One vote per recipe per browser, and you can change it. We keep only the stars: no name, e-mail or IP address. How ratings work
Tips for perfect rolls
- Weigh everything. Bread is a matter of ratios, so use digital scales for flour, yeast, salt and even the water (1 ml of water weighs 1 g). Use strong (bread) flour: its extra protein makes the gluten that holds the rise.
- Fresh or dried yeast. About 15–20 g of fresh yeast does the same work as one 7 g sachet of fast-action (instant) dried yeast, enough for 500 g of flour. Crumble fresh yeast into lukewarm liquid to dissolve it; stir fast-action straight into the flour. Keep salt and yeast apart until the liquid goes in.
- Lukewarm, never hot. Liquid at about 30°C (86°F) feels just warm on your wrist. Hot liquid kills yeast; a cool dough simply takes longer, and often tastes better for it.
- Knead until it passes the windowpane test. Knead until the dough is smooth and springy, then stretch a small piece gently between your fingers. If it thins to a translucent sheet without tearing, the gluten is ready; if it tears, knead for 2 minutes more and test again.
- Prove by eye, not by clock. Times depend on the warmth of your kitchen. After the first rise the dough should have about doubled; after shaping, rolls should look puffy and nearly doubled. Press a floured fingertip in: if the dent springs back slowly and only partly, it is ready; if it springs straight back, wait; if it does not spring back at all, bake straight away.
- Shape with tension. Weigh the pieces so they bake evenly, and roll each one under a cupped hand on an unfloured worktop until the surface is smooth and taut. A tight skin gives a rounder roll and a better rise.
- Steam for crust, cover for softness. For crusty rolls, pour boiling water into a hot tin on the oven floor as the rolls go in, and let the steam out after 10 minutes. For soft rolls, bake without steam and cool them under a tea towel.
- Is it done?. Tap the base of a roll: it should sound hollow. A probe thermometer is surer: crusty and wholemeal rolls 93–96°C (200–205°F); soft and enriched rolls (milk, butter, eggs) 88–90°C (190–195°F), which keeps them moist.
- Cool on a rack. Rolls finish setting as they cool. Cut too soon and the crumb is gummy. Freeze any you will not eat the same day, and refresh them in a hot oven for 5–8 minutes.
Variations
5 ways to change the main recipe. Each uses the same method unless it says otherwise.
Floury baps (Scottish morning rolls)
Use lard instead of butter, leave out the egg and add 30 ml (2 tbsp) more water. Shape as baps (step 6), dust heavily with flour and bake at 220°C (200°C fan), gas mark 7, 425°F for 12–15 minutes, so they stay pale and soft.
Batch or tear-and-share rolls
Pack the 12 balls 1 cm (½ in) apart in a greased 23 × 33 cm (9 × 13 in) roasting tin; they rise into each other and bake with soft sides. Allow 20–22 minutes and check the centre roll is done.
Finger and hot dog rolls
Divide into 10 pieces, roll each into a 15 cm (6 in) sausage and set them 1 cm (½ in) apart in a lined tin so they join as they prove. Bake 16–18 minutes and pull apart when cool.
Knots and plaits for the dinner table
Roll each 75 g (2½ oz) piece into a 25 cm (10 in) rope and tie in a single knot, or make 3 thinner ropes and plait them. Glaze with egg and scatter with poppy seeds before baking.
Make it in a bread machine (dough cycle)
Use the 7 g fast-action dried yeast, not fresh, and put everything in the pan in the order your manual gives: Panasonic machines want the yeast first, then the flour and other dry ingredients, with the liquid last; most other makes want the liquid first and the yeast last, on top of the flour. Cut the butter into small pieces and beat the egg into the milk and water. Choose the Dough programme and start it straight away: never use the delay timer with milk or egg. The full recipe suits a large (2 lb, 900 g–1 kg loaf) machine; for a 1.5 lb machine make three-quarters, and for a compact 1 lb machine (about 250 g flour, such as the Panasonic SD-PN100) make half. Then shape the rolls or baps, prove and bake as above.
Bread machines: the dough cycle for rolls → · Kneading and proving techniques →
See also
- Bread Rolls (Crusty) — lean, crusty white rolls baked with steam
- Bread Rolls Brown (Wholemeal) — light wholemeal rolls
- Milk Bread Rolls — Japanese-style tangzhong rolls, the softest of all
- Brioche Buns — rich, buttery burger buns
- Bread Rolls Pontypool Style — a big-batch Welsh bakery roll with lard
- Kneading and proving techniques — by hand, mixer, bread machine or no-knead; the windowpane and poke tests
- Bread machines — choosing one, settings, and the dough cycle for rolls
Chef’s notes
- Milk, butter, sugar and egg are what make these rolls soft: fat and sugar tenderise the crumb and keep it moist, and milk sugars give a golden, thin crust that browns at a lower oven temperature.
- Use strong flour, butter and no more than 20 g fresh yeast (or one 7 g sachet of fast-action dried yeast) for 500 g of flour, and bake at 200°C: too much yeast gives a beery taste and rolls that rise fast and then collapse.
- For burger buns, make 8 pieces of about 110 g (4 oz), flatten to 10 cm (4 in), glaze with egg and scatter with sesame seeds; bake 16–18 minutes. Toast the cut sides before adding the burger.
- They keep for 2 days in a bag. Freeze for up to 1 month; thaw at room temperature, or warm for 5 minutes at 180°C (160°C fan), gas mark 4, 350°F.
A little history
Small individual loaves are baked all over Europe, under many names: Brötchen or Semmeln in Germany and Austria, panini in Italy. Britain alone has the roll, bap, barm cake, batch, bread cake, bun, cob, teacake and muffin.
What you call one depends on where you grew up. In a 2018 YouGov survey of almost 25,000 people in England, 52% said “bread roll” or “roll”, the only name used across the whole country. “Bun” was the choice of most people in County Durham, Tyne and Wear and Northumberland, and “cob” of most in Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire. “Barm” or “barm cake” led in Greater Manchester, “teacake” came second in West Yorkshire and “batch” second in Warwickshire, while “bap” had its strongest following in Staffordshire, Cheshire and Shropshire.
The bap is Scottish. The Dictionaries of the Scots Language define it as a small, thick roll of bread, often diamond-shaped, baked in the oven: a morning roll. Their earliest example is from Allan Ramsay’s Tea-Table Miscellany of 1724, which promises “farls, and baps”, and F. Marian McNeill’s The Scots Kitchen (1929) gives a traditional bap of flour, salt, lard, yeast, sugar, milk and water, very close to our soft white rolls.
The barm cake, a soft, round, flattish roll from North West England, takes its name from barm, the yeasty froth that forms on fermenting ale. Barm was one of British bakers’ original sources of yeast; it faded from use in the 19th century as compressed yeast, the fresh yeast in our recipes, became widely available.
The Kaiser roll (Kaisersemmel) is Austrian: white flour, yeast, malt, water and salt, with the top cut or folded into five curved segments. It is often said to be named after Emperor Franz Joseph, but the name is already in print by 1825, more than twenty years before his reign began. Rolls very like it sit beside each plate in Martin van Meytens’s painting of a court dinner at the Hofburg in the 1760s, and under Austrian rule in Lombardy Italian bakers made a hollow version, the michetta or rosetta.
Brioche is French. The word is first recorded in 1404, and Randle Cotgrave’s French–English dictionary of 1611 describes it as “a rowle, or bunne, of spiced bread”, of Norman origin. The famous “let them eat brioche” (usually translated as cake) was not Marie Antoinette’s: Jean-Jacques Rousseau gives it to “a great princess” in his Confessions. Today brioche is a favourite burger bun.
Soft milk-bread rolls are a Japanese style. Bread spread in Japan after the Second World War, when relief shipments of wheat helped with rice shortages. The trick behind their softness, cooking a little of the flour in liquid first, comes from the Japanese yudane (or yukone) and was popularised across Asia as tangzhong by the Taiwanese cookery writer Yvonne Chen.
Sources for these notes
For the history above and the tips for perfect rolls.
- Wikipedia: Bread roll (European names; UK regional names: roll, bap, barm cake, batch, breadcake, bun, cob, teacake, muffin, citing YouGov 2018)
- YouGov (Matthew Smith, July 2018): “Cobs, buns, baps or barm cakes: what do people call bread rolls?” (archived copy)
- Dictionaries of the Scots Language (SND): bap (Ramsay 1724; McNeill, The Scots Kitchen, 1929)
- Wikipedia: Barm cake (North West England, traditionally leavened with barm)
- Wikipedia: Barm (froth on fermenting ale; an original source of yeast for British bakers; receded in the 19th century as compressed yeast spread)
- Wikipedia: Kaiser roll (name in print by 1825; van Meytens painting, 1760s; michetta / rosetta)
- Wikipedia: Brioche (first recorded 1404; Cotgrave 1611; Rousseau’s “great princess”; used for hamburgers)
- The Guardian (Zoe Williams, 2019): “Mmm bap: the long search for the perfect burger bun”
- Wikipedia: Japanese milk bread (bread spread in Japan after the Second World War; yudane)
- King Arthur Baking: Japanese Milk Bread Rolls (tangzhong from Japan’s yukone or yudane, popularised by Yvonne Chen; 65°C)
- King Arthur Baking (PJ Hamel): Using a thermometer with yeast bread (190°F benchmark; soft rolls dry out when baked hotter)
- King Arthur Baking: What is the windowpane test for bread dough?
- Red Star Yeast: Yeast conversion chart (one ¼ oz / 7 g package of dry yeast = about ⅔ oz / 17–19 g fresh cake yeast, for up to 4 cups of flour)
How this recipe was developed
We developed this soft white roll and floury bap following the bakers below.
- Milk, fat and sugar for softness. Dan Lepard’s soft white baps use milk, butter and sugar; Paul Hollywood’s floury baps use 8% shortening and 8% sugar. We use milk and water, 8% butter (or lard), 3% sugar and the card’s egg.
- Flatten for baps. Hollywood rests his dough balls for 10 minutes, then flattens them with a rolling pin and dusts them with flour; we give both soft rolls and baps.
- A moderate oven, no steam. Hollywood bakes baps at 220°C (200 fan) for 10–15 minutes; BBC Good Food’s rolls at 230°C. For soft rolls we use 200°C, no steam, and cool them under a cloth.
- Done at a lower temperature. King Arthur Baking found soft rolls fully baked, and moister, at about 88°C (190°F); we give 88–93°C.
Sources we compared (ratings as shown on each site on 1 November 2026):
- Paul Hollywood (The Great British Bake Off): Floury baps
- The Guardian (Dan Lepard): Soft white baps (2007)
- BBC Good Food (Barney Desmazery): Easy bread rolls (4.3/5 from 243 ratings)
- King Arthur Baking (PJ Hamel): Using a thermometer with yeast bread (2017)
- King Arthur Baking: What is the windowpane test for bread dough? (2022)
- Red Star Yeast: Yeast conversion chart
This is an original Cookeryonline recipe written in our own words. Ingredient choices and techniques are credited above; no source text has been copied.
Useful kit
- Digital kitchen scales: weighs flour, water, yeast and salt to the gram, and lets you divide the dough into even rolls. Amazon UK · Amazon US
- Plastic dough scraper: for sticky doughs, dividing and keeping the worktop clean. Amazon UK · Amazon US
- Instant-read thermometer: the sure way to tell when rolls are done. Amazon UK · Amazon US
- Baking stone or steel: a heavy, hot surface for crustier rolls with a better rise. Amazon UK · Amazon US
- Bread lame: a razor blade on a handle for clean slashes in crusty rolls. Amazon UK · Amazon US
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Shopping list for 12 portions
Dairy & eggs
Baking
Oils, vinegars & sauces
Store cupboard (check you have)
Revised in November 2026 from the Cookeryonline Excel workbook “SR6”.
