Know How · Techniques
Stuffing
Stuffing, also called forcemeat, is bread, onion, herbs and fat, with or without sausage meat, cooked in or beside a roast. Here is where the English stuffing for turkey and chicken came from, how much crumb, meat and onion the old cooks and today’s cooks use, how to balance the herbs, and how Chef Col makes it light, not claggy.
What stuffing is

A stuffing is a seasoned mixture that is cooked inside a bird or joint, or rolled into balls and baked beside it. The English kind is built on four things: breadcrumbs for body, onion for flavour, herbs such as sage and thyme, and fat to keep it moist. Sausage meat is often added; the old herb stuffings had little or none.
It has had many names. Farce (from the French farcir, to stuff) is recorded in English in the late 1300s and forcemeat from the 1680s. Seventeenth-century cooks wrote of a “pudding in the belly”. In the United States it is often called dressing, especially in the South, and some cooks keep that word for stuffing baked outside the bird. See also forcemeat and farce in our glossary.
A little history
For about two hundred years the English stuffing for turkey and chicken was bread-led: grated crumbs, suet or butter, parsley, thyme and lemon peel, sometimes a little ham or veal, bound with egg yolk. Sage and onion was for goose, duck and pork. Sausage meat crept in during the 1800s, and today’s sausage-heavy stuffing is the end of that change, not the old norm.
- Roman times. The Apicius collection stuffs a chicken with meat, cooked spelt grain, brains, eggs and nuts “to make a solid dressing”.
- About 1390. In The Forme of Cury, written by Richard II’s cooks, “Chykens in Hocchee” are stuffed with parsley, sage, garlic and grapes, then boiled. No bread.
- 1660. Robert May’s “pudding in his belly” is grated bread, sweet herbs, suet, egg yolks, cream, currants and sugar, and he recommends his herb puddings for stuffing turkey.
- 1747. Hannah Glasse stuffs a boned turkey with a pound of veal, “as much grated bread” and half a pound of suet: equal bread and meat.
- 1769. Elizabeth Raffald fills the turkey’s craw (the neck end) with the crumbs of a penny loaf, suet and only “a little sausage-meat or veal”.
- 1845. Eliza Acton’s forcemeat “for roast veal, turkeys” has no meat at all, just crumbs, butter, lemon, parsley and thyme. She fills the breast with it “or with the finest sausage meat”, and with chestnut forcemeat she fills the body with chestnuts.
- 1861. Mrs Beeton still fills the turkey’s breast with a bread forcemeat, but adds a sausage-meat stuffing for turkey and says sausage meat is “now a very general mode of serving fowl”.
- About 1900. Cassell’s New Dictionary of Cookery puts veal forcemeat in the crop and chestnuts in the body, and offers a turkey filled with sausage meat alone.
- 1901. John Crampton, a butcher in Eccles, launches Paxo. The first flavour was parsley, lemon and thyme; sage and onion came later. It took off in the 1950s and 60s as chicken got cheaper.
- 1944. The Ministry of Food’s Festive Fare stuffing uses 8 oz sausage meat to 4 oz breadcrumbs, with onion, prunes, apple and herbs.
The old cooks put the bread forcemeat at the neck (crop) end and, when they used two fillings, chestnuts in the body.
Crumb to meat: then and now
Where the old recipes give weights, the share of meat has risen steadily. “Meat” here means lean meat or sausage meat; suet and butter are not counted.
| Recipe | Crumbs | Meat | Crumb : meat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acton 1845, forcemeat for turkeys | 4 oz | none | 1 : 0 |
| Beeton 1861, forcemeat No. 417 | 6 oz | 2 oz ham | 1 : 0.3 |
| Glasse 1747, turkey the genteel way | 1 lb | 1 lb veal | 1 : 1 |
| Ministry of Food 1944 | 4 oz | 8 oz sausage meat | 1 : 2 |
| Beeton 1861, sausage-meat stuffing for turkey | 2 oz | 12 oz pork | 1 : 6 |
| Today’s UK recipes (our survey of 19, middle value) | e.g. Mary Berry: 150 g crumbs, 700 g sausage meat | about 1 : 5 | |
| Our English Stuffing | 200 g | 200 g sausage meat (plus 100 g lardons) | 1 : 1 |
So our English Stuffing, with equal weights of crumbs and sausage meat, sits with the classic Georgian and Victorian bread-led stuffings, at the same 1 : 1 balance as Glasse. A sausage-led stuffing is just as traditional in its own way, but it is the younger tradition. Both are good; they eat differently. Bread-led is lighter and crumblier; sausage-led is meatier and firmer.
How much onion?
Onion was left out of the old turkey forcemeats altogether. Acton wrote that onion “can be added” but did not seem to her “suited to the meats for which the forcemeat is more particularly intended”. Onion belonged to sage and onion stuffing, for goose, duck and pork, and there it was used generously and boiled first to soften its bite.
| Recipe | Onion | Crumbs | Onion cooked first? | Onion : crumb |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acton 1845, onion and sage (goose, duck, pork) | 3 large | “an equal quantity” | Boiled | about 1 : 1 by measure |
| Cassell’s, about 1900, onion and sage | 3 large | “an equal quantity” | Parboiled 20 min | about 1 : 1 by measure |
| Beeton 1861, sage and onion | 4 large | 4 oz | Parboiled about 5 min | about 9 : 1* |
| Ministry of Food 1944 | 1 medium | 4 oz | Not stated | about 1.5 : 1* |
| Today’s UK recipes (middle value) | about 1 onion per 400–450 g sausage meat | Mostly softened in butter | about 2.3 : 1* | |
| Our English Stuffing | 200 g | 200 g | Sweated in the bacon fat, then cooled | 1 : 1 |
* Estimates. The old recipes count onions instead of weighing them, so we have taken a large onion as about 250 g and a medium one as about 175 g (Delia Online’s guide). A Victorian “large onion” may not match today’s.
In a bread-led stuffing the onion is weighed against the crumbs, and the old rule was roughly equal amounts. In a sausage stuffing the meat sets the amount, about one onion to 400–450 g. Either way, cook the onion first. The Victorians boiled it; today we sweat it gently in fat until soft but not coloured, which gives the same mellow sweetness with more flavour. Raw onion is much sharper, as Beeton and Cassell both warned.
Our English Stuffing follows the old rule: equal weights of onion, breadcrumbs and sausage meat, 200 g of each.
Getting the herbs right
Parsley gets lost in a stuffing. Its flavour doesn’t survive the cooking. Sage, thyme and the other woody herbs carry much more flavour, so build on those.
Then make one choice: lead with one herb, or use a mix. In sage and onion, sage should lead, and dried sage especially can drown out everything else. A little thyme or rosemary behind it adds depth without stealing the show.
Chef ColThe science agrees. America’s Test Kitchen explains that the flavour of delicate herbs such as parsley, basil and chives is volatile and easily lost in drying and cooking. The flavour of sage, thyme, rosemary and oregano is far more stable and survives the oven.
Fresh or dried sage
- Dried herbs are roughly three times as strong as fresh by volume. The usual swap is 1 teaspoon dried for 1 tablespoon fresh.
- Dried sage is stronger and duller than fresh (fresh has the milder flavour), and it is easy to overdo. Add it a pinch at a time, and fry a little of the mix to taste before you shape the rest.
- Fresh sage should be finely chopped. Beeton blanched her sage leaves for “a minute or two to take off their rawness”. Some cooks soften it with the onion for the last minute instead.
How much the old cooks used
- Acton, 1845, turkey forcemeat: ¼ oz of herbs to 4 oz crumbs, two-thirds parsley and one-third thyme. She warned that no herb or spice “should be allowed to predominate powerfully”.
- Acton, 1845, onion and sage: ½–¾ oz of sage for three large onions. Here sage leads.
- Beeton, 1861: 10 sage leaves for 4 large onions and 4 oz crumbs in sage and onion; 1 small tablespoon of minced sage in her sausage-meat stuffing for turkey. For turkey forcemeat she says “no one flavour should predominate greatly”.
- Cassell’s, about 1900: “four fresh sage-leaves, or six dry ones” for a goose, and only “a small tea-spoonful of powdered sage” in its onion and sage stuffing.
So there have always been two styles: a gentle mixed-herb forcemeat for turkey and chicken, and a sage-led stuffing for the richer birds and pork. Our English Stuffing is sage-led, with rosemary and thyme in the background.
Chef Col’s way
Balance is everything. The onion brings the flavour and the breadcrumbs bring body and crunch, but too much crumb, or crumb that is too fine and wet, turns it claggy.
Leave the egg out. It helps hold the stuffing together, but it makes it heavier. A good stuffing holds without it, and if it needs a little help to bind into balls, add a little extra oil.
Chef Col- Use stale bread, lightly crumbed. Bread a day or two old makes light, dry crumbs that soak up the fat and onion juices without going to paste. Acton grated hers “very lightly into exceedingly fine crumbs”. Don’t pack them down.
- Fat holds it together. Without egg, the old binders were fat (butter, suet, or fatty sausage meat and bacon) and a little moisture.
- Won’t bind into balls? Add a little extra oil. Work it in, then squeeze each ball firmly in your hands so it holds. If the balls are still soft, chill them briefly before cooking.
- Still dry and crumbly? Add a splash of stock. Add just enough for the mix to hold when squeezed. Cassell’s moistened its sausage meat with “a little cold stock or water”. Stop before it turns sticky.
- Cook the onion, then cool it. Sweat it in the fat until soft, then let it cool before it meets raw sausage meat.
- Mix gently, by hand. Overworking makes it dense. Fry a small piece to check the seasoning before you shape the rest.
- Mind the meat. Sausage meat adds richness and holds the mix together; more crumb makes it lighter. Pick your style from the ratio table.
Cooking it safely

- Stuffing cooked on its own (balls, a tray or a loaf tin) must reach 75°C in the middle. Check with a probe thermometer.
- Neck stuffing in a roast chicken needs no separate check. It sits nearer the surface than the centre of the breast, so it is well above temperature by the time the breast reaches 72°C in its thickest part. That breast reading is the one that matters.
- Don’t pack the body cavity. A tightly filled cavity slows the cooking. For a turkey, goose or duck we cook the stuffing in a separate dish and put only onion, apple or herbs in the cavity for aroma.
- Make it ahead if you like and keep it in the fridge. Stuff the bird just before it goes in the oven.
Our stuffing recipes
- English StuffingEqual weights of crumbs, onion and sausage meat, led by sage
- Chestnut StuffingChestnuts, apricots and a little sausage meat
- Hazelnut StuffingHazelnuts, bacon and apricots; fills the turkey crown’s legs
- Apricot StuffingApricots, hazelnuts and sausage meat
- Roast Chicken with StuffingNeck stuffing in a Sunday roast
- Roast Turkey and GravyStuffing cooked alongside
- Turkey Crown with Stuffed LegsBoned legs rolled round stuffing
See also
Sources
- Apicius, Cooking and Dining in Imperial Rome, tr. J. D. Vehling (1936), recipe 248 (Project Gutenberg)
- The Forme of Cury (about 1390), ed. Samuel Pegge (Project Gutenberg)
- Robert May, The Accomplisht Cook (1660; 1685 edition) (Project Gutenberg)
- Hannah Glasse, The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy (1747; 1774 edition) (Wikisource)
- Elizabeth Raffald, The Experienced English Housekeeper (1769; 1773 edition) (Internet Archive)
- Eliza Acton, Modern Cookery for Private Families (1845; 1882 edition) (Project Gutenberg)
- Isabella Beeton, The Book of Household Management (1861) (Project Gutenberg)
- Cassell’s New Dictionary of Cookery (about 1900) (Internet Archive)
- Grace’s Guide: Paxo
- The Wartime Recipe Challenge: Ministry of Food Festive Fare (1944) stuffing
- Online Etymology Dictionary: forcemeat, farce
- Dictionary.com: Stuffing vs. dressing
- America’s Test Kitchen: Substituting dried herbs for fresh
- The Spruce Eats: Cooking with fresh and dried sage
- Health Canada: Best uses for fresh and dried herbs
- Delia Online: Knowing your onions (onion weights)
Written for Cookeryonline in November 2026 from the sources above, a survey of 30 modern stuffing recipes and our own recipes. Ratios from old recipes are worked out from the quantities they print; estimates are marked.

