Vegetable Dishes
Red Cabbage
Recipe No. 0572
Slow-cooked red cabbage with smoked bacon, juniper and Granny Smith apples, cooked on the hob, covered then reduced to a glossy coating. Change the portions and units below and the amounts update.
- Serves 4
- About 2 hours (about 1½ hours covered on a low heat, then about 30 minutes uncovered)
- British
Why we cook it this way
We cook this on the hob, not in the oven: covered on a low heat so the cabbage softens in its own steam, with the vinegar keeping the colour, then with the lid off when the apples and sugar go in, to drive off liquid and glaze the shreds so they stay tender but hold their shape. It is quicker to watch than an oven pot, and it frees the oven for the roast.
This is a savoury red cabbage: smoked bacon, juniper and bay, with the sugar added when the lid comes off. Of the 22 recipes we compared, 20 cook covered for the main stage; this recipe used to simmer uncovered for two hours, topping up with water. We now cook it covered for about 1½ hours on a low heat, until the shreds are just tender, then take the lid off for about 30 minutes.
Ours also starts with more liquid than most, so the water is 100 ml rather than 200 ml, and the lid stays off for about the last 30 minutes, until the liquor has reduced to a glossy coating. There is no flour or other thickener. Diced Granny Smith apples go in when the lid comes off, so they take on the red of the cabbage and keep some shape. We use cider vinegar, and keep the 50 g of sugar, because Granny Smiths are tart.
Method
Before you start
- Quarter the cabbage, cut out the core, and shred it evenly.
- Peel, core and dice the Granny Smith apples (150 g), then hold them in a bowl of cold water with a squeeze of lemon juice so they do not go brown. Drain them just before they go in, when the lid comes off, so they take on the red of the cabbage and keep some shape.
- Cut the bacon into lardons and chop the onion.
- Have a lid that fits the saucepan ready.
In a large saucepan, melt the butter or heat the olive oil. Fry the bacon lardons, then add the onion and the shredded cabbage and cook for a few minutes.
Add the cider vinegar, water, bay leaf and juniper berries. Cover and cook gently on a low heat for about 1½ hours, until the cabbage shreds are just tender but still hold their shape. Give it a little longer if the shreds need it.
Take the lid off. Drain the apples and stir them in with the sugar. Cook uncovered for about 30 minutes, until the liquid has reduced to a glossy coating, not a loose sauce.
Taste for the balance of cider vinegar and sugar, and for salt from the bacon. Remove the bay leaf.
Serve with the glossy liquor.
Tip: tap a step to tick it off as you cook.
Rate this recipe
Tried it? Rate it.
The readers’ average appears here once 5 readers have rated it.
One vote per recipe per browser, and you can change it. We keep only the stars: no name, e-mail or IP address. How ratings work
Varieties
These are sourced variations on this pot, not separate recipes. The main recipe keeps the smoked bacon, juniper and bay.
- German Rotkohl. Apple, cloves and bay, often with red wine or juice, and sometimes a little juniper (Emmi uses 2–3 berries/kg; piccolomaxi uses 3/kg). The fat in the German recipes we compared is usually pork or goose fat, or butter. Four of those six finish with flour. In the north the name is Rotkohl; in the south it is Blaukraut.
- British apple and spice. Cooking apples or Granny Smiths, onion, cinnamon and cloves, often under a tight lid or in the oven, as in the Delia reproduction, the BBC Berkshire sheet, Good Food and Ramsay.
- Different vinegars and wine. In the 22 recipes, the named vinegars are cider or apple vinegar, red-wine vinegar, balsamic, wine vinegar (type not further specified) and spirit vinegar. Some pots also use red wine, dry cider, or apple or grape juice. Nigella uses no vinegar. We have not listed malt vinegar, because it does not appear in this survey.
- Vegetarian (no bacon). Leave out the 50 g smoked bacon and cook in butter or oil. Plenty of the recipes we compared have no bacon; they rely on butter, apple and spices, not a smoked substitute.
- Vegan (no bacon). As the vegetarian variety, but use oil, not butter, and a vegan-labelled sugar (this recipe has no eggs, milk or honey). Do not add smoked paprika or other bacon substitutes: none of the 22 recipes use them.
See also
Chef’s notes
- Use 25 g butter or 25 ml olive oil. Olive oil is a modern option; it is not named in the 22 recipes we compared.
- The Granny Smiths are peeled, cored and diced, then held in cold water with a squeeze of lemon juice so they do not brown, and drained just before they go in. Peeling is our choice — the survey does not say whether to peel them. Peeling helps the dice take on the red of the cabbage, and the skins can stay chewy in a long, slow cook.
- For the covered stage, allow about 1½ hours on a low heat, but go by texture as well as the clock: shred width, pan and heat all change the time. The shreds should be just tender and still hold their shape.
- Taste at the end for the balance of cider vinegar and sugar, and for salt from the bacon, before adding more salt. 100 ml cider vinegar for 400 g cabbage is at the high end of the survey.
- Take out the bay leaf before serving.
- If the pan looks dry during the uncovered stage, add only a splash of water. The point of the last half hour is a glossy coating, not a loose sauce, and we do not thicken with flour.
- For a vegetarian pan, leave out the bacon and use butter or oil. For vegan, leave out the bacon, use oil not butter, and check that the sugar is vegan-labelled. There is more under Varieties, above.
A little history
Sweet-and-sour red cabbage is a European family of dishes, not a single invention. Raw, pickled and fermented cabbage are a different line from the slow, hot pot. In 1581 Marx Rumpolt recorded briefly cooked, cooled red cabbage dressed with vinegar and oil: that is a salad, not the modern festive dish, but it does show an early pairing with acid.
German cookbooks of 1830–1859 document covered cooking with wine, vinegar and butter (1830), optional sugar (1844), and a bacon, onion, apple, wine, vinegar and sugar formula (1859). These are examples, not proven firsts. In Britain, Charles Elmé Francatelli (1852, recipe 213) stewed thinly sliced red cabbage under a lid with dripping or butter and vinegar. Isabella Beeton (1861, recipe 1099) cooked it with diced ham, butter, stock and vinegar, added sugar after covered cooking, then reduced the liquor — a parallel to this recipe’s savoury meat base and late sugar, not proof of descent. Denmark’s official cultural account dates Christmas rødkål to the 1800s. In Germany the northern name is Rotkohl and the southern name is Blaukraut (Mazur-Stommen, 2003; Destatis). That confirms a wider European festive tradition; it does not prove transmission into British cookery.
How other cooks vary it
The notes below come from a desk survey of 22 recipes, completed on 18 November 2026: this recipe as it then stood, eight UK and named-chef recipes, seven US publisher recipes, and six German Rotkohl recipes. The amounts and times are those cooks’ own, and are not interchangeable. We have not treated per-kilogram ratios or website ratings as proof of a better flavour.
Two caveats sit in the table. The Delia row is an attributed reproduction (Bennison Farm); the official Delia page was not accessible for the survey. The Heston row is a leaf-triangle garnish, not a shredded sweet-and-sour pot.
| Cook | Fat / bacon | Fruit | Vinegar | Sugar, jelly and liquid | Spices | Lid and time | What stands out |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heston / Everdure | 50 g butter; 30 g pork jelly | None in the cabbage | 20 g red-wine vinegar | 250 g port; 100 g cabbage juice; no separate sugar | None added to the cabbage (spices are in the pork) | Uncovered reduction, about 15 min (inferred) | A leaf-triangle garnish, not a shredded sweet-and-sour pot. Juniper belongs to the pork, not the cabbage. |
| Delia Smith (reproduction) | 15 g butter; no bacon | 450 g cooking apples / 1 kg cabbage | 3 tbsp wine vinegar | 3 tbsp brown sugar; no other liquid listed | Garlic, nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves; no juniper | Oven, tight lid, 120–150 min (oven temperature not in the reproduction) | Attributed Bennison Farm reproduction; the official Delia page was not accessible. A classic layered apple-and-spice oven model. |
| Jamie Oliver | 4 bacon rashers; 1 tbsp oil | 2 apples; 100 g prunes | 6 tbsp balsamic | No separate sugar; juice of 1 clementine | Rosemary, fennel, clementine zest; no juniper | Hob, lid ajar; 20–25 min for the cabbage, about 35 min overall | A quick hob method, with fruit and juice for sweetness. |
| Gordon Ramsay Restaurants | 100 g butter; no bacon | 1 Bramley apple / 600 g cabbage | 100 ml red-wine vinegar; lemon juice | 100 g demerara; no other liquid listed | Cinnamon sticks, star anise, cloves, lemon zest; no juniper | Hob, then oven 160°C / 140°C fan, under wet baking paper and a lid; about 90 min in the oven | A high-vinegar, high-sugar, high-butter formula. The wet paper and lid limit evaporation. |
| Nigella Lawson | No added fat; no bacon | Cranberries (dried and fresh or frozen); no apple pieces | None listed | 2 tbsp dark brown sugar; 750 ml apple juice | Cinnamon and ground cloves; no juniper | Open boil 10 min, then a tight lid for 90–120 min | Fruit and apple juice supply both tartness and sweetness. |
| Raymond Blanc | 40 g butter / 2 kg; no bacon | None listed | 50 ml balsamic | 200 g redcurrant jelly; 250 ml each orange juice, port and water | Cinnamon, star anise, orange zest; 30 juniper berries, ground with salt | Hob, then oven 150°C with a lid; 80 min in the oven, plus a 30 min cure | The same juniper count as this recipe, at 15 berries/kg. |
| BBC Berkshire | 10 g butter; no bacon | 450 g cooking apples / 900 g cabbage | 3 tbsp wine vinegar | 3 tbsp brown sugar; no other liquid listed | Garlic, nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves; no juniper | Oven 150°C, tight lid, 120–150 min | A BBC Berkshire sheet, not a BBC Food recipe. Close to the Delia reproduction, with more nutmeg. |
| Good Food / Cathryn Evans | 25 g butter / 1.5 kg; no bacon | 4 Granny Smith apples / 1.5 kg cabbage | 3 tbsp cider vinegar | 100 g brown sugar; 300 ml dry cider | Orange or clementine zest; mixed spice; no juniper | Hob, lid on; bring to the boil, then 90 min simmer | Granny Smiths named for a covered hob cook with cider. |
| Epicurious / Bon Appétit | ¼ cup butter; no bacon | No fruit | 1 tbsp wine or cider vinegar | No sugar; 3 tbsp wine or hard cider | None beyond seasoning; no juniper | Hob, uncovered (inferred from stirring); about 30 min | A short open-pan butter-and-wine method. |
| Allrecipes / Jeanette | 2 tbsp butter; no bacon | 1 cup apple | ⅓ cup cider vinegar | ¼ cup sugar; 3 tbsp water | Ground cloves; no juniper | Hob, covered, 90–120 min (the header says 65 min, which does not match the directions) | A family sweet-and-sour cider-vinegar pot. The card time and the method do not agree. |
| Simply Recipes | 2 tbsp butter; no bacon | No fruit | ¼ cup balsamic | 2 tbsp sugar; no other liquid | None beyond seasoning; no juniper | Hob, covered after sautéing; simmer 30–45 min | A shorter balsamic formula, without apple. |
| Serious Eats | 140 g bacon; 28 g butter | 300 g apples / 652 g cabbage | 30 ml balsamic | No sugar; 240 ml each juice and stock | Garlic, caraway, parsley; no juniper | Hob, covered 25 min, then uncovered 8–12 min | A savoury bacon base with a short uncovered reduction. |
| Martha Stewart | 2 tbsp butter; no bacon | 1 apple | 2 tbsp cider vinegar | 4 tsp sugar; ½ cup water | None listed; no juniper | Hob, covered, 20–25 min plus 4–6 min | A fast covered apple and cider-vinegar hob method. |
| Food Network Kitchen | 3 bacon slices; no extra fat listed | 1 Granny Smith apple / 1.35 kg cabbage | 125 ml red-wine vinegar | 1 tbsp sugar; 375 ml each wine and water | Allspice, cinnamon, bay; 8 juniper berries | Hob, covered about 60 min, then uncovered about 5 min | The closest structural relative to this recipe (bacon, onion, juniper, bay), with a short uncovered finish. |
| Saveur / Mary Sue Milliken | ½ cup duck fat or bacon drippings | No fruit | 1 cup red-wine vinegar | ½ cup sugar; no other liquid | Caraway, bay; no juniper | Hob, covered, about 60 min after the aromatics | A high red-wine-vinegar pot without apple. |
| Emmi | 50 g clarified butter (or oil); no bacon | 1 sour apple / 1 kg | 2 tbsp apple vinegar, adjusted at the end | 2 tbsp sugar; 300 ml water; 50 ml grape juice or wine at the end | Cloves, bay; 2–3 optional juniper berries | Hob, covered, about 45 min, longer if needed | A German covered hob Rotkohl, with optional juniper and an acid adjustment at the end. |
| Chefkoch / geiga | 125 g pork fat; no bacon rashers listed | 6 apples / 2.3 kg cabbage | About 94 ml spirit vinegar | 1 × 125 ml cup sugar; water as needed | Bay, cloves; no juniper | Hob, lid on, about 120 min, plus about 8 min flour finish | A long covered cook finished with flour. The source cup is 125 ml, not a US cup. |
| Chefkoch / piccolomaxi | 50 g butter | 1 small apple / 1 kg | A splash of red-wine vinegar, adjusted | 2 tbsp brown sugar; 100 ml each apple juice and red wine | Cloves, bay, allspice; 3 juniper berries | Hob; lid not stated; at least 60 min | A caramelised apple Rotkohl with a little juniper (3 berries/kg). |
| Chefkoch / Herta | 2 tbsp goose or pork fat | 2 apples, or 1 jar apple sauce | 2 tbsp red-wine vinegar | 3 tbsp sugar; 500 ml red wine; stock as needed | Cloves, cinnamon, bay; no juniper | Hob; lid not stated; 30–45 min, then flour and wine until soft | Finished with a flour roux rather than by reducing the liquor. The title uses both Rotkohl and Blaukraut. |
| Chefkoch / Elfi | 60 g pork or goose fat | 3 sour apples / 1 kg | 2 tbsp vinegar, adjusted | Sugar to taste; 2 tbsp redcurrant jelly; 125 ml water | Bay and cloves (amount unstated); no juniper | Hob; lid not stated; about 120 min, plus a flour finish | A long, slow cook sweetened with sour apples, jelly and sugar to taste. |
| GuteKueche.de | 50 g pork fat or butter | 2 sour apples / 1 kg | A splash of vinegar | 1 tbsp sugar; 250 ml water; a splash of wine at the finish | Cloves, bay; no juniper | Hob; covered for the final 40 min | A shorter covered hob Rotkohl, finished with flour and a splash of wine. |
Sources for these notes
- Culinary History Archive — Of Rotkohl (Marx Rumpolt, 1581, and German cookbook transcriptions of 1830, 1844 and 1859).
- Francatelli, Charles Elmé (1852). A Plain Cookery Book for the Working Classes, recipe 213: Stewed Red Cabbage.
- Beeton, Isabella (1861). The Book of Household Management, Chapter 25, recipe 1099: Stewed Red Cabbage with Ham.
- Denmark.dk (official website of Denmark): cultural history of Danish Christmas rødkål (19th century). The research names this site; it does not give a deeper page address.
- Mazur-Stommen, Susan (2003). Anthropological study of northern German holiday foodways (fieldwork 1984–2000).
- Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis): overview of German Christmas culinary traditions (Rotkohl / Blaukraut). The research does not give a page address.
- The 21 recipe links in the survey table, and Cookeryonline’s Red Cabbage research and comparison workbook, 18 November 2026.
Research behind the recipe
These notes are from a desk survey of 22 recipes, completed on 18 November 2026, not from a kitchen trial. The comparison covered this recipe as it then stood, eight UK and named-chef recipes, seven US publisher recipes, and six German Rotkohl recipes. Quantities and times in the table belong to those cooks and are not interchangeable.
The current recipe follows that survey and the decisions of 18 November 2026: cider vinegar, less water, a covered cook on the hob for about 1½ hours, with the lid off for about the last 30 minutes (about 2 hours cooking in total), Granny Smith apples added at that point (held in lemon water until then), butter or olive oil, and no thickening. A kitchen trial is still useful before the covered time, the vinegar quantity, or any make-ahead advice can be locked.
The original recipe is from the Cookeryonline archive. The comparison and the historical notes are from Cookeryonline’s Red Cabbage research of 18 November 2026.
Shopping list for 4 portions
Meat & poultry
Fruit & veg
Dairy & eggs
Oils, vinegars & sauces
Fresh herbs
Store cupboard (check you have)
Converted from Cookeryonline’s original recipe archive.
